Parker: 97

Despite a hailstorm that destroyed approximately one-third of the crop this year, Paul-Vincent Avril managed to produce a wine with the same grape proportions as in previous years, thanks to his vineyard's diverse and fragmented nature. So, the 2022 Chateauneuf du Pape from Clos des Papes reveals a delicate, aromatic bouquet of peony, gooseberry, lilac, flowers and cherries mingled with delicate notes of fennel and menthol. Medium to full-bodied, sappy and layered, it's perfectly textured with velvety, delicate tannins enhanced by bright acids and a long, ethereal finish. Although the Mourvèdre is slightly dominant at this stage, this wine is unquestionably poised for great aging potential.

The 2022 vintage at Clos des Papes has turned out exceptionally well, producing wines with beautifully balanced structures and aromatic bouquets, bright acids and tension, despite losing one-third of the crop to an August hailstorm. Paul-Vincent Avril, a conscientious vigneron, understands that nature is not always generous. Like his ancestors, he has ensured the estate covers a reasonably large area. The vineyard is scattered across the various terroirs and sectors of Châteauneuf-du-Pape, planted with a mix of all authorized grape varieties, concentrating on Grenache for the reds and Clairette and Grenache Blanc for the whites. The estate now spans nearly 35 hectares, divided into 24 parcels. The soils are meticulously cultivated to encourage deep rooting, enabling the vines to better withstand the heat and droughts so common in this part of France. Yields are carefully controlled through practices such as short pruning, severe de-budding and occasionally green harvesting in early August. The estate has been certified organic since 2010. Mr. Avril made changes in the cellar in 1992, avoiding whole bunches and extending the maceration period without pumping over or punching down the cap (pigéage) to add more structure in the mid-palate. All maturation takes place in foudres of 43–65 hectoliters, and since 1988, there has been no filtration before bottling. Clos des Papes’s red and white wines are known for their finesse, ethereal quality, aromatic complexity and capacity for aging.

Dunnuck: 98

The 2022 Châteauneuf Du Pape is showing beautifully, with the sun-kissed style of the vintage yet more depth and density than most in the vintage. Blackberries, Provençal garrigue, spice, and saddle leather all define the aromatics, and it hits the palate with the classic elegance of the estate in its medium to full-bodied, layered, multi-dimensional style. It's one of the wines of the vintage and will have two decades of longevity.